
In the vast pursuit to increase computer speed, some upgrades obviously give you faster computers, including, but not limited to, faster processors, more RAM, and many more options. But one topic I come across quite frequently is does laptop hard drive speed really matter, and more specifically, is it worth the money to upgrade? If you read the “Gaming 101” article I wrote, you can see that hard drives are one of the last things I said to spend upgrade money on, especially if that money is highly limited. So, if you’re to the point where you’ve got the extra money to upgrade hard drive speed, or you’re just curious, let’s address some issues.
The most common speeds today are 5400RPM and 7200RPM, some slow drives still run at 4200RPM, and you’ve got some elite drives like the Raptors than run at 10,000RPM. But for comparison purposes, we’re going to mainly look from the 5400RPM to the 7200RPM. Now just to start, I went to several (and by several, I really do mean several) laptop sites, and the average upgrade price from a hard drive of the same size going from 5400RPM to 7200RPM was approximately $50. In the world of laptop upgrades, $50 is hardly a large amount, when you upgrade a processor 0.1 GHz you’re looking at spending more than $100 in some cases. But either way, $50 is still $50 out of your pocket, so let’s continue.
7200RPM is obviously faster than 5400RPM, so there are going to be slight differences, but whether these differences are worth it are up to you. First of all, there is usually a couple ms (millisecond) time difference in reading and writing seek time, which is basically loading and saving files. Again, we’re talking about time differences on the millisecond level, which over time can add up, but the most is perhaps a minute lost out of your day, unless you’re doing some serious photo or video editing with hundreds of files. The slightly bigger difference you will see is in transfer rates, which usually increase by about 5-10 MB/s (numbers can range quite a bit, some were as low as 2 MB/s, while some where as high as 22 MB/s).
Now, moving on to some more technical aspects, several tests have been run by several different companies using WorldBench. If you are not familiar with it, WorldBench is basically test software that scores performance based on application scripting. And, in even more simpler terms, it can help tell you which things, whether they are computers, or different parts within the same computer, are faster/better.
The differences in scores between 5400RPM and 7200RPM ranged slightly, but in the end the average difference was no more than a couple points (if any). The only programs that really produce a difference between the drives are compression programs (like WinRAR), video editing programs (like Adobe Premiere), and CD writing programs (like Nero, also note that this takes into account writing data form the hard drive onto a CD). Here, differences were actually rather large, up to 100 second differences in Adobe Premiere, and up to several hundred seconds in Nero. So if you plan to use these programs frequently, upgrading the drive for $50 is definitely worth it.
Furthermore, the load times of several programs was also lowered, but the most any program was lowered by was approximately 5 seconds. So if loading really annoys you, then I suppose upgrading your drive might be worth it, but don’t really expect your computer to run all that much faster.
So, in the end, is it worth it to upgrade? Well, the answer really depends on what you’re doing. In general, I would probably opt for the upgrade just because I tend to do photo, video, and music editing. Plus, a $50 difference in a laptop that costs thousands of dollars hardly seems valuable to skimp on. But then again, if none of those things interest you, you’ll be just fine with the 5400RPM drive. One of the more interesting things is that, even more so than the differences in speed (5400RPM vs 7200RPM), some hard drive brands clearly outperformed others. In some instances, the 5400RPM version of some hard drive brands even outperformed the 7200RPM version of other hard drive brands. I’m not going to name any names right now, but look for an article in the near future comparing brands.